Skip to main content

· Updated 17 Nov 2026· Written by

Vietnam Buyer Withholds Payment over Alleged Defects: Evidence for Sellers

A Vietnamese customer says the shipment is defective and withholds payment. Overseas sellers should check governing law, CISG inspection and notice rules, batch-level evidence, remedies and recovery options.

Luật sư Trần Việt Tùng
Reviewed byLawyer Trần Việt TùngManaging PartnerLegally reviewed on 17 Nov 2026
Vietnam Buyer Withholds Payment over Alleged Defects: Evidence for Sellers

A Vietnamese buyer cannot necessarily avoid paying an invoice simply by alleging that delivered goods are defective. The seller should first establish which law governs the sale, whether the buyer gave a timely and sufficiently specific non-conformity notice, what the evidence shows, and whether withholding all or part of the price is legally justified.

The answer differs between a domestic sale governed by Vietnamese commercial law and an international sale governed by the UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG). A seller should not rely on Vietnam's domestic payment-suspension rules without first examining the governing legal regime.

1. Which law governs the buyer's quality complaint?

When an overseas seller contracts with a company in Vietnam, three questions should be addressed separately: the substantive law governing the contract, the dispute-resolution forum, and the jurisdiction where a decision may need to be enforced.

The CISG may govern an international sale when the parties' places of business are in different Contracting States and the conditions of Article 1 are met, or through applicable private international law rules. The parties may exclude it under Article 6. The Convention applies to sales of goods within its scope; the location or nationality of shareholders is not decisive. Mixed supply-and-service arrangements require a separate scope analysis under Article 3.

Vietnam became a CISG Contracting State on 1 January 2017 and maintains an Articles 12 and 96 declaration relating to form. This declaration should be reviewed when the alleged contract or amendment rests on informal communications. It does not mean that every email exchange is necessarily ineffective; the form question requires proper legal analysis.

If the CISG does not apply, a valid governing-law clause and relevant conflict-of-law rules must be considered. For a transaction governed by Vietnamese commercial law, Articles 39–41 and 50–51 of the Commercial Law 2005 are particularly relevant.

IssueVietnamese commercial saleInternational sale governed by CISG
Quality standardContractual specification and Article 39Contract and Article 35
Inspection and noticeContractual process; Articles 44 and 318 where applicableArticles 38–40, including specific notice duties
Price obligationArticle 50; possible suspension under Article 51Articles 53 and 58; remedies and any lawful withholding need separate analysis
Remedies for defectsCure, appropriate contractual/statutory remediesArticles 45–50 and damages provisions
Entire contract avoided?Requires contractual/statutory grounds, including fundamental breach rulesArticle 49 generally requires fundamental breach in a non-conformity case

The table is a starting point, not a licence to mix provisions from both regimes.

2. What should the buyer actually prove about the goods?

Quality disputes are decided against the agreed benchmark, not against a broad statement that the shipment was “unusable”. For an international sale, Article 35 CISG looks first to the quantity, quality, description and packaging required by the contract. Where the parties have not agreed otherwise, the Convention also addresses ordinary fitness, a particular purpose made known to the seller, samples or models, and proper packaging.

The seller should retrieve the purchase order, specifications, approved samples, inspection terms, packing requirements, amendments and relevant correspondence. If the buyer says the goods failed an internal standard, ask whether that standard was incorporated into the transaction before delivery.

A credible defect allegation should identify the shipment and lot, number of affected units, failed parameter, testing method, date of inspection and the requested remedy. If the disputed goods have been processed, mixed with other stock or discarded, the seller should record how that affects verification.

An independent test report may be valuable, but the seller should examine the sampling plan, accreditation and scope of the laboratory, chain of custody, date of sampling and whether the report covers the particular goods delivered. A report on a different lot may not establish non-conformity of the invoiced shipment.

Passing risk does not necessarily end quality liability

Under Article 36 CISG, the seller may remain responsible for a lack of conformity existing when the risk passed, even if it becomes apparent afterwards. Defects arising later because the seller breached a guarantee or other obligation may also be covered. Conversely, deterioration caused by the buyer's later storage or handling is not automatically attributable to the seller.

Incoterms, transport records and delivery signatures are relevant to delivery and risk allocation, but do not conclusively establish that all quality warranties have been met. The terms of the specific Incoterms rule and the contract must be checked rather than treating a bill of lading or proof of delivery as a universal acceptance certificate.

3. Did the Vietnamese buyer inspect and notify in time?

For a CISG sale, Articles 38 and 39 are central. The buyer must examine the goods, or cause them to be examined, within as short a period as practicable in the circumstances. Where the contract involves carriage, examination may be deferred until arrival as permitted by Article 38.

Under Article 39(1), the buyer risks losing the right to rely on non-conformity if it does not notify the seller, specifying the nature of the problem, within a reasonable time after discovery or when it ought to have discovered it. Article 39(2) contains an outside two-year notice limit from actual handover, unless inconsistent with a contractual guarantee period. Two years is not a general two-year grace period for sending any quality complaint: the Article 39(1) reasonable-time requirement still matters.

Articles 40 and 44 provide qualifications in defined circumstances. In particular, a seller that knew or could not have been unaware of the relevant facts and failed to disclose them cannot necessarily rely on the buyer's failure to comply with Articles 38–39.

For a seller, the immediate exercise is to build this timeline:

  1. Contract and applicable specifications agreed.
  2. Goods dispatched, risk allocated and physical delivery completed.
  3. Buyer had a reasonable opportunity to inspect.
  4. First complaint was received, including what it actually said.
  5. Seller asked for samples or proposed a joint inspection or cure.
  6. Buyer withheld payment, specifying invoices and amounts.

If the first written complaint simply says “quality problems, payment on hold”, ask for the precise defect and the affected lots. Keep the buyer's original message rather than replacing it with a later paraphrase.

4. Can the buyer withhold the entire invoice under the CISG?

There is no simple rule that every quality complaint automatically suspends the full purchase price. Article 53 requires the buyer to pay the price and take delivery in accordance with the contract and Convention. Article 58 addresses when payment becomes due, subject to the parties' terms and the Convention's conditions.

Buyers may have specific remedies for non-conforming goods, including demanding performance or cure in appropriate circumstances, reducing the price under Article 50 and claiming damages under Articles 45 and 74. Whether a buyer may withhold payment temporarily, and to what extent, can involve contested interpretation of the Convention, contractual conditions and the circumstances of the case. A seller should not concede a blanket withholding right merely because the buyer cites “CISG defects”.

Price reduction is different from keeping the whole invoice unpaid. Under Article 50, the price reduction is calculated by comparing the value of the goods actually delivered at the time of delivery with the value conforming goods would have had at that time, subject to the Article's qualifications. It is not always equal to the buyer's estimated rework expenses or to the nominal invoice value of disputed units.

Avoidance is more serious. Under Article 49, the buyer generally needs a fundamental breach in the case of non-conforming goods to avoid the contract. It must also satisfy applicable requirements about the declaration and timing. A minor or remediable deviation cannot simply be labelled “fundamental” to escape payment.

If the buyer claims a set-off against another contract, examine whether the applicable law and parties' agreements permit it. A complaint concerning one shipment does not automatically establish a right to withhold unrelated debts.

5. What if the buyer has already accepted or resold the shipment?

Receiving goods, signing a warehouse receipt or reselling them may be significant evidence, but none of these events alone answers every quality question. A delivery receipt usually establishes receipt and possibly quantity; it may not test a hidden chemical or mechanical property.

The seller should examine how and when the goods were used, whether the defect could have been discovered at receipt, and what happened during storage, processing or onward distribution. If the buyer has resold the goods, seek customer returns, complaint records, production traceability and representative samples where legally available.

Where the buyer refused to allow timely verification but continued using or disposing of the goods, document this carefully. Do not destroy your own production samples, batch data or inspection records after a dispute begins.

6. How should the seller respond to a withholding notice?

A practical response should be neither a blanket denial nor an unconditional admission. It should identify the invoices and shipments in question, ask for evidence, and propose a verifiable way to investigate.

StepSeller's actionExpected documentary result
Verify contractIdentify governing law, agreed specifications, inspection and payment clausesContract matrix
Verify shipmentsMatch PO, invoice, packing list, transport and delivery recordsShipment-by-shipment chronology
Investigate defectsRequest samples, test data, lot numbers and storage historyDefect-evidence schedule
Respond formallyReserve rights, propose testing/cure and request payment of undisputed sumsDated formal response
NegotiateAgree on replacement, repair, credit note or payment schedule where justifiedSigned or otherwise valid settlement
EscalateReview forum, time limits, debtor assets and cost of recoveryDispute assessment and claim schedule

For example, assume a hypothetical shipment of 2,000 components valued at USD 100,000. The buyer alleges that 150 units are defective and withholds the full USD 100,000 invoice. The nominal value of 150 units may be USD 7,500 if the unit prices are uniform, but that does not automatically fix the legally permitted withholding amount. The units might be inseparable from a critical system, or the buyer's defect claim may lack proof. Examine the actual contractual purpose, remedy, evidence and applicable law before negotiating an amount.

A settlement can identify an undisputed portion to be paid immediately, a test protocol for the disputed stock, who pays for verification and a date for reconciling any price adjustment. Avoid a settlement clause that unintentionally waives interest or other claims unless the business intends to do so.

7. Can the seller demand interest, damages or sue in Vietnam?

If the buyer fails to pay a legally due amount without a valid defence, the seller may pursue the price and applicable interest or other remedies. Under Article 78 CISG, interest may be due on a sum in arrears; the rate requires further legal analysis because the Convention does not itself provide a universal numerical rate.

Where Vietnamese commercial law governs, Article 306 contains a statutory rule on late-payment interest, subject to agreement and other applicable provisions. Under Article 51(4), a buyer that suspends payment on inauthentic evidence in the specified cases and causes loss may also face a separate damages claim. The seller must avoid automatically importing this rule into a CISG-governed dispute.

Before proceedings, review any arbitration clause or valid court agreement, the forum's jurisdiction, the applicable limitation rules and enforcement prospects. A foreign seller may instruct Vietnam counsel remotely for an initial document review, but court or arbitration proceedings can require appropriate corporate authorisations, translations and document formalities.

Evidence to preserve before involving counsel

  • Contract, purchase order, amendments and confirmed specifications.
  • Original emails and relevant chat records with full context.
  • Packing lists, transport documents, delivery confirmations and inspection certificates.
  • Retained samples, batch traceability and manufacturing quality records.
  • Buyer's first defect notice and all subsequent testing exchanges.
  • Invoices, bank remittances, credit notes and a precise outstanding-balance schedule.
  • Evidence of any agreement to inspect, replace, repair or settle.

8. What does a Vietnamese court decision illustrate?

A published 2020 first-instance commercial judgment (05/2020/KDTM-ST, Tây Ninh) involved a buyer claiming certain PET deliveries were defective. The court found that the photographs and assertions submitted, without suitable examination and against the contractual delivery-check process, were insufficient to establish those alleged defects. Importantly, the case also concerned a deposit, cessation of deliveries and a later repayment arrangement; the court ultimately ordered the seller to return VND 485.4 million. See the published judgment.

This case illustrates an evidentiary issue, not an across-the-board rule that a buyer who signs a delivery note loses every quality claim. Nor is it an international CISG decision. It should not be presented as proof of foreign buyers' search demand or as a Justix case study.

Instructing local counsel is useful where the Vietnamese buyer disputes several shipments, withholds sums disproportionate to the alleged defect, challenges inspection protocols or raises a Vietnamese-law defence despite a different governing law.

Justix handles commercial contract and payment disputes. Depending on the engagement, the work may cover governing-law and evidence review, a shipment-by-shipment claim assessment, demand correspondence, settlement strategy and preparation for court or arbitral proceedings. Specific deliverables can be a legal assessment, defect-evidence checklist, payment schedule or dispute-resolution documents.

A persuasive claim starts by proving what was delivered, what quality was promised, what the buyer reported and which amount is presently payable. Those answers should determine the recovery strategy—not the mere fact that the buyer has raised a quality objection.

Legal basis

  • United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG): Arts. 1, 3, 6, 12, 35–40, 44–50, 53, 58, 62, 74, 78 and 96, where applicable.
  • Vietnam Commercial Law 36/2005/QH11: Arts. 39–41, 44, 50–51, 55, 306, 312–313 and 318–319 if Vietnamese commercial law governs.
  • Vietnam Civil Code 2015: applicable conflict-of-laws rules for contracts involving a foreign element, subject to applicable treaties and forum rules.
  • Vietnam Civil Procedure Code 2015, as amended: evidentiary and jurisdictional rules where a Vietnamese court is competent.
  • Published first-instance Judgment 05/2020/KDTM-ST (27 August 2020): public Vietnamese domestic dispute, not a CISG case or Justix engagement.

This article is for general information and reflects the law at the time of publication. Please contact a lawyer for advice on your situation.