Skip to main content

· Updated 17 Nov 2026· Written by

Vietnamese Buyer Claims Force Majeure: Can You Still Recover Payment?

A force majeure notice does not automatically discharge unpaid purchase money. Assess the governing law, payment impediment, evidence and separate claims for price, interest and damages.

Luật sư Trần Việt Tùng
Reviewed byLawyer Trần Việt TùngManaging PartnerLegally reviewed on 17 Nov 2026
Vietnamese Buyer Claims Force Majeure: Can You Still Recover Payment?

A Vietnamese buyer does not automatically escape payment for delivered goods by sending a force majeure notice. The seller should test the governing law, the contractual allocation of risk and the evidence linking the alleged event to the particular payment; exemption from damages is not the same as cancellation of the outstanding price.

For an international sale governed by the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), Article 79 is particularly important: it provides a conditional exemption from liability for damages, while paragraph 5 preserves other rights. A domestic Vietnamese-law analysis has its own rules and should not simply be substituted for that treaty analysis. CISG, Articles 62 and 79

1. Identify the contract, the buyer and the applicable rules

The starting point is the sales contract—not the nationality of the person who emailed the force majeure notice. Confirm the seller and buyer named in the contract, their relevant places of business, any assignment or guarantee, and the entity that actually received the goods or made earlier payments.

A Vietnamese subsidiary and its overseas parent should not be treated as one debtor merely because both use the same branding. Equally, an English-speaking creditor may be a company established in Vietnam rather than an overseas exporter. These distinctions determine which contract and connecting factors need review.

For a foreign-element contract assessed under Vietnamese conflict-of-laws rules, Article 683 of the Civil Code addresses choice of law and the closest connection where an effective choice is absent. Choosing a forum and choosing the substantive law are separate decisions. Civil Code, Article 683

The CISG may apply to an international sale within its scope unless effectively excluded. Selecting the law of a CISG Contracting State does not, by those words alone, necessarily exclude the Convention. Vietnam's participation took effect on 1 January 2017; the actual contract date, scope, places of business and any relevant declarations still need checking. CISG, Articles 1, 6 and 100 · UNCITRAL status information

If the CISG does not govern, identify the applicable domestic law before using its remedies or interest rules. The Vietnamese buyer's location is not a sufficient reason to apply every provision of Vietnam's Commercial Law automatically.

2. Separate the price claim from the consequences of delay

A force majeure dispute becomes easier to analyse when the demands are separated.

Claim or proposed actionQuestion to resolve
Outstanding purchase priceWas the sum due, and has any valid agreement or legal event discharged or changed it?
InterestWhat provision authorises it, on which sum and for which period?
DamagesDoes the proven impediment exempt the buyer from liability for the relevant failure?
Contractual penaltyIs the clause valid under the applicable law, and does an exemption cover it?
Extension, suspension or terminationDoes the contract or governing law actually permit the proposed step?

Under the CISG, Article 62 addresses the seller's right to require payment, subject to the Convention's conditions and the qualification in Article 28 concerning a court's obligation to order performance. Article 78 separately provides for interest on a sum in arrears. Article 79 is not a general debt-release provision, and a successful exemption argument does not itself eliminate the price claim. CISG, Articles 28, 62, 78–79

Interest should not simply be relabelled as damages and waived on that basis. The Convention does not specify a single interest rate for every case; the applicable approach, agreement and circumstances require separate analysis. The CISG Advisory Council's Opinion No. 14 also distinguishes the entitlement to interest from the damages exemption. CISG Advisory Council, Opinion No. 14

Where Vietnamese domestic commercial law governs, examine Articles 294–296 alongside the payment duty, available remedies and Article 306 on overdue-payment interest. Do not assert either that all interest must always survive force majeure or that all interest is automatically waived. The exemption, contract wording and affected period must be analysed. Commercial Law, Articles 50, 294–297 and 306

3. Ask what actually prevented payment—not simply what harmed the business

Article 79(1) of the CISG requires proof of an impediment beyond the party's control that it could not reasonably have been expected to take into account when contracting, or to avoid or overcome, including its consequences. The claimed impediment must explain the actual failure to pay. CISG, Article 79

A buyer saying “our market collapsed” presents a different evidential problem from a buyer showing that a lawful transfer could not be processed despite timely, complete instructions. Neither description should be accepted or rejected without checking the facts.

Cash-flow failure and downstream customers

Ask whether the buyer is unable to fund payment, unable to sell the goods profitably, or unable to collect from its own customers. Those facts may explain distress, but they do not by themselves establish every element of Article 79 or the Vietnamese statutory test.

The allocation of financing and resale risk matters. So does timing: an event known when the payment commitment was made raises a different foreseeability issue from an exceptional obstacle arising later.

A blocked or interrupted payment process

For an alleged transfer obstacle, request the specific payment instruction, rejection or hold notice, date, reason, missing documents and steps taken to resolve the issue. Determine whether the restriction covers that payer, payee, currency or transaction, and whether another lawful arrangement was reasonably available.

An assertion that “the bank will not remit” is not an adequate description on its own. A bank may be waiting for information that the buyer—or the seller—was contractually required to provide. Article 54 of the CISG includes the buyer's obligation to take the steps and comply with formalities required to enable payment. Article 80 prevents a party from relying on a failure to the extent that its own act or omission caused it. CISG, Articles 54, 79–80

Alternative arrangements must comply with the relevant banking, sanctions and regulatory rules. Do not propose personal accounts, false invoices or undisclosed intermediaries to bypass a restriction. Where a documentary credit is involved, the bank's undertaking and applicable credit rules require their own review; this article addresses the buyer's underlying price obligation.

4. Build an invoice-by-invoice evidence schedule

The practical issue is often not whether an external event occurred, but which payments it affected and for how long. Prepare one schedule that can be used by the finance team, management and counsel.

Evidence categoryWhat the seller should establish or request
Contract and due dateSigned terms, purchase orders, accepted changes, payment triggers and any force majeure clause
Performance and priceDelivery records, transport documents, agreed price, required supporting documents and amounts received
Event and timingOfficial decision or incident record, commencement and end dates, scope of the alleged restriction
Direct payment effectTransfer instructions, bank responses and transaction-specific reasons for non-payment
Response and alternativesDocuments submitted, requests for clarification and lawful options considered
Remaining exposureUnaffected invoices, earlier arrears, interest periods and any disputed deductions

An event certificate can be relevant evidence. It is not a substitute for analysing causation, foreseeability, mitigation and the legal consequences under the particular contract. Request only relevant records that can lawfully be disclosed; account credentials and unrelated customer information are unnecessary.

Preserve original emails, attachments and complete message threads. A bilingual chronology can help avoid disputes about whether a communication merely acknowledged receipt of the notice or actually accepted a payment extension.

Hypothetical example: an invoice is due on 31 March. A documented banking interruption begins on 10 April and ends on 13 April. The later interruption does not, by itself, explain the buyer's earlier arrears. Any possible relief during the interruption must be assessed separately, including whether the buyer was ready and able to make the transfer and whether the impediment actually prevented it. This is an illustration, not a Justix client matter.

5. Audit the force majeure clause and the notice

A clause may list natural disasters, government measures or other events yet still exclude payment obligations or already-accrued debts from relief. Read its operative language: what obligations are covered, what must be proved, what notice is required, and what remedy follows?

If Vietnamese commercial law applies, Article 294(1)(a) recognises agreed exemption cases, while force majeure itself is addressed in Article 294(1)(b). Under Article 294(2), the party invoking an exemption bears the burden of proving it. The definition in Article 156 of the Civil Code and the liability rule in Article 351 are also relevant. Commercial Law, Article 294 · Civil Code, Articles 156 and 351

Notice rules differ. Article 295 of the Commercial Law requires prompt written notification of the exemption circumstances and their possible consequences, as well as notification when they cease. Under CISG Article 79(4), the notice must reach the other party within a reasonable time; liability may arise for damages resulting from non-receipt. Neither rule should be reduced to a universal statement that any late notice automatically defeats the entire exemption, irrespective of the contract. Commercial Law, Article 295 · CISG, Article 79(4)

A seller's response should identify unanswered questions and avoid inadvertently accepting a revised due date. However, a “reservation of rights” label cannot override the legal effect of a clear agreement or inconsistent conduct.

6. What the published Vietnamese arbitration example shows

A public VIAC case summary describes a Vietnamese buyer resisting payment to a Korean seller by citing financial crisis and business difficulties. The tribunal rejected the argument, including for inadequate proof and foreseeability. It is an illustration—not a binding rule that every payment-related force majeure defence fails, and not a Justix case. VIAC case summary 058

The useful lesson for preparing a claim is to answer the actual defence with contract-specific documents. A general report on an industry downturn does not answer which invoice could not be paid, why lawful payment was impossible and what the buyer did about it.

7. Choose the next step without accidentally weakening the claim

Request clarification and payment of unaffected amounts

Respond to the notice in writing, identify the sums claimed and distinguish those the buyer says are affected. A useful request might read:

We acknowledge receipt of your notice but have not agreed that it discharges the price obligation or changes the contractual due dates. Please identify the affected invoices, the relied-upon clause and legal basis, the impediment's start and end dates, and records showing its effect on the relevant payments and the measures taken to overcome it. Please also confirm your position on amounts not affected by the alleged impediment.

Adapt the wording to the governing law and existing correspondence. A requested evidence-response date is not necessarily a new payment date. Do not describe a chosen response period as a statutory deadline.

Negotiate a documented solution where commercially justified

A temporary, evidenced obstacle may justify a controlled payment arrangement. Record the principal balance, any disputed portion, revised dates, treatment of accrued and future interest, security and the consequences of a further default.

Vietnam has a CISG declaration relevant to written form. Review Articles 12 and 96 and the applicable formal requirements when documenting an amendment; do not assume that an informal chat message resolves all questions of form or authority. CISG, Articles 12 and 96 · UNCITRAL status information

If the seller fixes an additional period for payment under CISG Article 63, the provision has consequences for exercising remedies during that period. A demand letter should therefore distinguish a document request, a negotiated extension and a formal additional period for performance. A general reservation cannot remove statutory consequences. CISG, Article 63

Escalate based on evidence and enforceability

Where the buyer does not substantiate its claim or honour an agreed arrangement, review litigation or arbitration rather than issuing indefinite reminders. Check the actual dispute-resolution clause, the debtor's identity, relevant assets, service requirements and likely enforcement route.

Article 79 does not decide jurisdiction, and the CISG does not supply a universal limitation period. For a claim governed by Vietnam's domestic Commercial Law, Article 319 provides the general two-year period subject to its exceptions; that period must not automatically be transplanted to every cross-border claim. Commercial Law, Article 319

8. Avoid treating force majeure as a licence for self-help

The seller should not assume it may seize delivered goods, stop every remaining shipment or terminate immediately merely because the buyer's explanation appears weak. The conditions for suspension, avoidance or termination must be assessed under the contract and applicable law. For CISG transactions, Articles 63, 64 and 71 may be relevant, depending on the facts. CISG, Articles 63–64 and 71

Likewise, damage to goods after risk has passed is a separate question from discharge of the price. Article 66 of the CISG preserves the payment obligation following loss or damage after risk transfer, except where attributable to the seller's act or omission. Vietnamese Commercial Law Article 50(3) contains its own rule on post-transfer loss or damage. Determine the applicable risk allocation rather than assuming that destroyed stock means no payment is owed. CISG, Article 66 · Commercial Law, Article 50

A request to renegotiate because performance has become commercially onerous also needs separate analysis. If Vietnamese Civil Code Article 420 applies, its requirements and renegotiation mechanism do not create an automatic right to stop performing; paragraph 4 addresses continued performance unless otherwise agreed. Civil Code, Article 420

9. What to send Vietnamese counsel for an initial review

The most useful initial package is the contract and amendments, the force majeure notice, a concise invoice schedule, delivery and payment evidence, the buyer's explanation and the relevant bank or regulatory documents. Include the dispute-resolution clause and a chronology distinguishing original due dates from proposed new dates.

An initial document assessment can be coordinated remotely. Formal proceedings may require authorisations, translations and other document formalities, which should be checked for the actual forum and documents rather than assumed to be identical in every case.

Through its commercial debt recovery and dispute-resolution services, Justix can review the asserted exemption, identify evidential gaps, separate the price and ancillary claims, and prepare a response or dispute strategy within an agreed engagement. Deliverables may include a legal assessment, an invoice-by-invoice exposure schedule, a demand or response letter and a settlement or proceedings plan.

The practical objective is a supportable recovery decision: identify what remains payable, what defence genuinely needs answering and whether an agreed solution or formal claim offers a realistic route to collection.

Legal basis

  • Vietnam Commercial Law No. 36/2005/QH11; consolidated text No. 113/VBHN-VPQH dated 27 August 2025: Articles 50–51, 294–297, 300, 303, 306, 308–315 and 319.
  • Vietnam Civil Code No. 91/2015/QH13: Articles 156, 351, 420 and 683
  • United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), where applicable: Articles 1, 6, 12, 28, 54, 62–64, 66, 71, 78–80, 96 and 100.

This article is for general information and reflects the law at the time of publication. Please contact a lawyer for advice on your situation.