Skip to main content

· Written by

Paid a Vietnamese Supplier but No Goods Arrived: Recovery Steps

An overseas buyer that paid a Vietnamese supplier but received no goods should check delivery obligations, the governing law, CISG remedies, payment evidence and the realistic options for shipment or refund.

Luật sư Trần Việt Tùng
Reviewed byLawyer Trần Việt TùngManaging PartnerLegally reviewed on 16 Nov 2026
Paid a Vietnamese Supplier but No Goods Arrived: Recovery Steps

If you paid a Vietnamese supplier but the goods have not arrived, you may be entitled to demand delivery, avoid or terminate the sale contract, and seek repayment, depending on the contract and applicable law. The safest starting point is to establish what the seller promised, whether delivery was actually due, what the bank transfer paid for, and whether the seller has delivered at the contractual delivery point. A supplier's silence does not, by itself, prove fraud or automatically make the entire advance refundable.

For an overseas buyer, the problem is often compounded by distance: you may have a signed contract, a remittance confirmation and a WhatsApp conversation, but no reliable evidence of the cargo's location or of the supplier's current status in Vietnam.

1. Has the Vietnamese supplier actually failed to deliver?

A missing shipment at the destination is not always the same as contractual non-delivery. Begin with the sale contract, purchase order and agreed delivery term.

CheckEvidence to requestWhy it changes the analysis
Contracted goodsSpecification, quantity, agreed packing and inspection requirementsIdentifies the obligation being breached
Delivery deadlineFixed date, shipment window, production milestoneEstablishes when a claim becomes ripe
Delivery pointContract wording and any incorporated Incoterms® ruleDelivery to a carrier may differ from arrival at destination
DocumentsBill of lading, airway bill, packing list, inspection certificatesHelps establish whether and how goods were dispatched
PaymentBank remittance, invoice, beneficiary detailsLinks an advance to the correct seller and transaction

For example, under some shipment terms the seller may complete its delivery obligation before cargo reaches the overseas buyer. A vessel delay may therefore require a different legal analysis from a seller that never procured or dispatched the goods. Incoterms rules matter only insofar as incorporated into the transaction and must be read alongside the agreement and applicable law.

For a Vietnamese-law-governed domestic or commercial sale, Article 37 of Vietnam's Commercial Law 2005 addresses delivery timing. International sales may instead fall under the UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), subject to its scope and the parties' arrangements.

2. Is the transferred amount an advance, a deposit or a security payment?

The label used in a pro forma invoice or a bank-transfer reference is not conclusive. An international trader may call the first instalment a deposit even when it is simply an advance against the purchase price.

There are three distinct possibilities:

Advance payment of price. This is money paid before a later delivery. A claim to its return normally depends on the contract, a valid remedy for non-performance or an agreed refund mechanism.

Security deposit under applicable domestic law. If Vietnamese Civil Code Article 328 properly applies, special deposit consequences may arise when the receiving party refuses to enter into or perform a contract, subject to the statutory requirements and any different agreement. This is not an automatic result of writing “30% deposit” on an invoice.

A contractual payment with negotiated forfeiture or refund conditions. The legal effect depends on the actual clause and the law governing validity and remedies. A provision using a familiar English commercial term may not produce the same result under every applicable legal system.

If the CISG governs an international sale, restitution following valid avoidance is primarily examined under Articles 81 and 84. The CISG does not simply convert a prepaid price into a Vietnamese Civil Code deposit with an automatic double-return sanction.

3. Which law governs a purchase from Vietnam?

A Vietnamese seller's location does not settle the question by itself.

The parties may have selected governing law and a dispute-resolution forum in the contract. Even where they chose a national law, the CISG may form part of the applicable sales law unless validly excluded and the Convention's conditions are met.

The CISG generally applies to qualifying international sales of goods between parties whose places of business are in different Contracting States, or in other cases covered by its Article 1 and the relevant private international law analysis. It excludes certain transactions and does not resolve every issue of contract validity, ownership or security arrangements.

Vietnam has been a CISG Contracting State since 1 January 2017. The UNCITRAL status table also records Vietnam's declaration under Articles 12 and 96 concerning the Convention's freedom-of-form provisions. Do not rely uncritically on Article 11 to assert that every oral or informal agreement involving a Vietnamese party is enforceable.

A buyer based in a country that has not joined the CISG should not assume the Convention automatically applies merely because the seller is Vietnamese. The governing-law clause and conflict-of-laws rules require individual assessment. Likewise, an arbitration clause and a choice-of-law clause perform different functions.

4. Can you insist on shipment instead of requesting a refund?

Yes, that may be commercially preferable if the goods remain useful, the supplier is operating and delivery is still feasible. It can also be a better first step where the breach is a short delay and the buyer cannot yet establish a right to avoid the contract.

For transactions governed by the CISG, Article 46 addresses the buyer's right to require performance, subject to its conditions. Under Article 47, a buyer may fix an additional period of reasonable length for the seller to perform. Article 49 then provides specific circumstances in which the buyer may declare the contract avoided, including non-delivery after an appropriate additional period under Article 47.

A notice requesting delivery should identify the outstanding quantity, the agreed shipping terms, the deadline and the shipping evidence required. If you fix an additional period, make it reasonable in the circumstances and avoid inadvertently granting indefinite extensions.

For a Vietnamese-law-governed sale falling under the Commercial Law, Article 297 provides the remedy of specific performance and Article 298 addresses a reasonable additional period. The right remedy still depends on the contract, breach and applicable provisions.

5. When can the buyer cancel the deal and demand the money back?

This is usually the most consequential decision. Neither mere frustration nor a few unanswered messages automatically rescind a contract.

Under the CISG, Article 49 permits avoidance if the seller's failure amounts to a fundamental breach or, in a case of non-delivery, where the seller fails to deliver within the additional period fixed under Article 47 or declares it will not do so. The buyer must give notice of avoidance under Article 26. Additional restrictions may become relevant once goods have been delivered.

After effective avoidance, Article 81 provides for restitution of what a party paid or supplied. If the seller must refund the price, Article 84(1) requires interest on it from the payment date. The Convention does not itself specify a universal interest rate, so that question requires separate legal analysis.

Under Vietnamese Commercial Law, Articles 312–315 distinguish the grounds and consequences of contract cancellation, including the need to notify the other party. Article 314 deals with the parties' rights to recover benefits supplied or received after cancellation, subject to the statutory scheme.

Before issuing a refund demand, decide whether you seek avoidance of the entire transaction or only undelivered instalments. A seller may have supplied part of the order; any restitution calculation must address that performance and avoid double recovery.

Hypothetical example: An overseas buyer pays USD 40,000 against two batches. The first batch, worth USD 15,000, is delivered and retained; the second is never shipped. The buyer should not demand the full USD 40,000 without explaining the contractual treatment of the received goods and whether it is avoiding the entire agreement or only the second batch.

6. What evidence should an overseas buyer preserve?

Build a single chronology with documents for each event. Focus especially on whether the bank beneficiary is the same legal person as the contractual seller.

EvidencePractical check
Signed contract and amendmentsLegal names, delivery terms, governing law, arbitration/court clause
Pro forma and commercial invoicesWhether they match goods, beneficiary and agreed price
Remittance confirmations, SWIFT messagesPayment date, value, beneficiary bank, recipient account
Email, WhatsApp, WeChat or other messagesOriginal conversation, identity of sender, shipment promises
Shipping and customs documentsCarrier authenticity, tracking number, bill of lading particulars
Supplier verificationRegistration name, address and representative of the Vietnamese entity
Replacement purchase or loss evidenceAdditional costs and mitigation efforts

A bank confirmation proves that a payment instruction or transfer occurred; it may not alone prove the supplier received the amount or that the payment relates to the disputed order. Bank statements, beneficiary confirmation and contract references should be reconciled.

A PDF bill of lading or tracking screenshot should be checked, where practical, with the relevant carrier or logistics provider. Keep original electronic files and metadata. Do not attempt to gain unauthorised access to the seller's systems or private accounts.

If your contact asks you to pay a different beneficiary at the last minute, verify the change independently with an authorised company representative before making any further payment.

7. The Vietnamese seller has stopped responding: what should you do?

Act on two tracks rather than waiting indefinitely for a reply.

Commercial and evidence track. Confirm the seller's registered details, contractual contact point and any known shipping arrangements. Preserve the timeline, send a written request for shipment status, and ask for objectively verifiable transport documents. Where the seller responds, obtain a specific delivery date or repayment proposal.

Financial and legal track. Contact the remitting bank promptly to ask about tracing or potential recall procedures. A wire recall is not a guaranteed reversal; it depends on the payment system, timing and receiving-bank cooperation. In parallel, assess a formal notice of breach and preservation of available evidence.

Do not assume that a supplier's silence is necessarily criminal fraud. A criminal complaint may be appropriate only if the facts support identifiable criminal conduct, such as evidence of deception at the point of contracting or misappropriation. Ordinary late delivery remains primarily a contractual issue unless additional facts support a different legal characterisation.

For overseas buyers unable to visit Vietnam, local counsel can check available corporate information and coordinate lawful document service or discussions. Such engagement does not guarantee the supplier can be located or the funds recovered.

8. What other amounts can you claim?

Separate repayment of price from contractual penalties, interest, damages and costs. The supporting law and evidence may differ for each category.

Price restitution. Depends on an effective right to unwind the transaction, a contractual refund clause or another legally supported basis.

Damages. Under CISG Article 74, recoverable loss depends on the convention's requirements, including foreseeability; Article 77 addresses mitigation. Under Vietnamese Commercial Law Articles 302–305, actual loss, causation, proof and mitigation are important. Replacement purchases must be documented rather than estimated casually.

Penalties. If Vietnamese Commercial Law governs, Articles 300–301 regulate agreed contractual penalties, generally subject to the statutory 8% ceiling on the value of the breached obligation, with legal exceptions. That figure should not be automatically imported into a CISG-governed contract without assessing the relevant law governing penalty clauses.

Interest. Under CISG Article 84(1), an obligation to refund the price includes interest from payment. The appropriate rate requires a further legal basis. Not every domestic overdue-payment interest rule governs restitution.

Costs of proceedings and enforcement. Recoverability must be checked against the applicable procedural rules, agreement and forum. Do not assume that every lawyer fee and recovery expense will be awarded.

9. Which forum should hear the dispute, and can it be managed remotely?

Review the dispute-resolution clause before sending an arbitration notice or filing a court claim. Check whether the arbitration institution exists, the seat, language, governing rules and the scope of the clause. A claim before Vietnamese courts requires a separate jurisdiction analysis; there is no universal rule that all disputes against a Vietnamese supplier must be filed in Vietnam.

Also consider where the seller's assets are located. An award or judgment may have to be recognised or enforced in a different jurisdiction. The ability to obtain a favourable decision and the ability to collect are separate questions.

Initial evidence review, notices and negotiations may often be coordinated remotely. Formal proceedings may require powers of attorney, corporate records, certified translations or consular formalities, subject to the forum and any applicable exemptions. Overseas buyers should check those requirements before dispatching originals.

If Vietnamese Commercial Law applies, Article 318 provides default commercial complaint periods subject to agreement and exceptions; Article 319 generally prescribes a two-year limitation period for commercial disputes, subject to statutory exceptions. Other applicable regimes, including international conventions and foreign laws, require a separate time-bar analysis.

10. A practical recovery sequence

  1. Stop further unsecured payment while verifying the transaction and the seller's position.
  2. Preserve the record: contract, invoices, bank proofs, original messages and shipping documentation.
  3. Determine the breach: compare the agreed delivery point and deadline with what actually happened.
  4. Choose one principal objective: shipment by a defined deadline or a legally supported exit and refund, with alternative claims structured consistently.
  5. Issue a formal notice: identify the obligation, relief sought, evidence and any additional performance period required by governing law.
  6. Verify the debtor's response and assets: do not accept open-ended reassurance as a substitute for documented performance.
  7. Review forum, limitation and enforceability before commencing proceedings.

A buyer can carry out the early evidence and shipping checks internally. Legal assistance is more useful where the advance is material, the supplier disputes contractual terms, the seller is unresponsive, goods are only partly delivered or cross-border enforcement is likely.

Justix advises on commercial contract disputes involving Vietnamese counterparties. Depending on the agreed engagement, work may include reviewing the sale contract and remittance evidence, preparing an assessment of enforceable claims, drafting a shipment or refund demand, negotiating settlement and assembling documents for litigation or arbitration. The deliverable and scope should be confirmed from the actual file; recovery and case outcomes cannot be guaranteed.

Legal basis

  • CISG: Articles 1, 12, 26, 46–49, 74, 77, 81, 84 and 96, subject to actual applicability.
  • Vietnam Commercial Law 2005: Articles 37, 297–298, 300–305, 312–315, 318–319 if Vietnamese domestic commercial law governs.
  • Vietnam Civil Code 2015: Article 328 where deposit/security law is relevant; do not assume any advance is an Article 328 deposit.

This article is for general information and reflects the law at the time of publication. Please contact a lawyer for advice on your situation.